NELA, KBK Attorneys Urge Third Circuit to Reverse Overly Restrictive Interpretation of Whistleblower Law
The National Employment Lawyers Association (NELA), as well as its Western and Eastern Pennsylvania affiliates, recently filed an amicus brief in a case before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, Lisenby v. Olympus Corporation of the Americas. In the brief, the organizations urge the court to reinstate a whistleblower retaliation claim under the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), which provides broad protections from retaliation to employees of federal contractors. KBK attorneys Michael Filoromo, Matthew LaGarde, Kelsey Woodford, and Bonnie Henry assisted with the drafting of the brief on behalf of NELA. Rachel McElroy of the McElroy Law Firm also contributed to and filed the brief.
This case concerns allegations that Lisenby, an executive at Olympus, discovered design and testing failures in a surgical camera device, which failed in 75 percent of cases. When he reported these concerns, including possible violations of FDA quality regulations, to several senior Olympus officials, he was subsequently terminated in what he alleges as retaliation.
The federal district court dismissed Lisenby’s NDAA claim, applying what NELA argues is a far stricter standard than Congress intended in holding that the plaintiff had not engaged in protected activity. NELA argues that decisions analyzing other whistleblower statutes, as well as the history and policy goals of the NDAA, support a broad interpretation of the law’s protections. Moreover, employing a stricter standard would chill the whistleblower reporting these laws are designed to encourage.
Read the brief here.